Wednesday, 03 January 2007
Minor Rituals of Death
Before moving to Portland, Maine last June, I had lived in my apartment in Greenwich Village for 23 years. When I bought it in 1983 it was, in my 42nd year, the 42nd move of my life which tells you a bit about the restlessness of my early years. But I learned in those years that there is no better way to clear out the detritus than to move. Who wants to add to the weight the moving company will charge for, for things you don’t need anymore.
So when I was packing for this 43rd move, I was ruthless in dumping two decades of what George Carlin famously calls “stuff”. Well, sort of ruthless. There were three items which, as my arm moved each toward the trash bag, I couldn’t part with.
All three had originally been my mother’s: a particularly ugly jewelry box; a little, metal container for rolls of stamps with her initials engraved on it; and her address book – small, green and, after the thank yous following her memorial service, useless to me.
I don’t know why I can’t part with these three items and I still have them. Today, I am reminded of the address book and of all the times I have wrestled with myself about removing – or not – the names of people in my own address book who have died.
There have been way too many over the years and particularly back in the days when I kept contact information in books like my mother’s instead of on the computer, I would see the names of the dead from time to time and tell myself I should cross them out if for no other reason than to make it easier to find who I was looking for.
But I never did. I didn’t want to erase them from my life like that. Sometimes, although not always, when I was transferring everything to a new address book (remember when we used to do that?), I would even copy them over. Nowadays, I just leave everyone in my electronic address book – dead or alive.
But today, I am confronted with a new, although similar, question.
Over there on the left in the Elderbloggers blogroll is a link to Donald M. Murray, weekly columnist for the Boston Globe, who died on 30 December. He wasn’t really a blogger, but I included him because there is (oops – “was”) no one else alive writing so eloquently about getting old.
I am heartbroken that there will be no new columns from Mr. Murray and my dilemma, as with address books, is what to do about his link. It goes to the page where the Globe lists his four most recent columns until they moved the oldest, each week, into the paid archive. Undoubtedly, after a reasonable period of time, they will remove that page and the link will be useless.
But I am loathe to lose his name from the list. On the other hand, I don’t want dead (so to speak) links hanging around my site which make any blog appear unkempt and out of date and, after all, the living must go on.
What to do, what to do?
Posted by Ronni Bennett at 06:03 AM | Permalink | Email this post
Comments
How about designating various different sections to the side roll: Current Favourites, Quickly Becoming Favourites, Old Favourites, Still Interesting, Forever Wise?
In your case you could put the links of those who have retired or temporary left off writing, or have died, in the Forever Wise category.
Don’t you find that your interest in certain blogs sometimes waxes and wains over time? I even had a R.I.P. Blog section for those blogs that I once enjoyed, but whose authors discontinued writing. Eventually, I deleted this section.
Posted by: lilalia on Jan 3, 2007 7:33:56 AM
Why don't you just "grey" his name. It would work for anyone who dies. Links will still work so long as someone pays the hosting bills
Posted by: Jill on Jan 3, 2007 9:08:11 AM
Two ideas... the first was to leave his name there but to delete the link (or perhaps link to your post on his passing)... or create a Memorial category.
I have a couple of friends whose names I haven't removed from my address list, but I thought it was just me.
Posted by: AlwaysQuestion on Jan 3, 2007 9:39:51 AM
I know just what you mean about old address books - but - sometimes they've been useful in finding a forgotten name of someone one's lost touch with and wants to find again when visiting that old hometown.
Perhap you could persuade the Globe to keep an active archive of all Murray's articles, then your link can remain active. And maybe have "late" with his name?
Posted by: marja-leena on Jan 3, 2007 10:55:00 AM
I like the idea of a Memorial category, but what about email? My dear friend died, but his email address remains. I continue to send messages to it hoping that somehow he is reading them.
Posted by: B.M. Gainer on Jan 3, 2007 10:56:47 AM
Interesting thought and I would go with what some said above with a special listing under some title for those writers who have died or no longer do it but have meaningfully added to the store of knowledge over the years. Not forgotten but understood to be no longer out there actively.
Posted by: Rain on Jan 3, 2007 11:25:43 AM
Ronni,
it reminds me of a dear friend who died suddenly coming up on two years ago. He's in my mobile phone contact list still - it just doesn't feel right to delete him.
john
Posted by: john Allsopp on Jan 3, 2007 3:41:08 PM
Ronni,
I have started three times to leave a comment, and deleted each one. They sounded contrite and silly.
You shall mourn the passing of your friend in ways such as this post. Your sharing the story of your mother's mememtos strikes a chord in all of us. Donald would certainly agree.
In the big scheme of things, if only one person remembers us after we're gone, then we haven't totally died and left a blank empty spot.
It is the remembering that is important, not the manner.
Posted by: Cowtown Pattie on Jan 3, 2007 3:43:01 PM
Just leave it there, and when you finally get tired of paying to look at his columns--or the paper removes them completely--you can remove it. In the meantime, you can think of him every time you see it. My condolences to you.
Posted by: Xtreme English on Jan 3, 2007 4:31:32 PM
I suppose because I can hear the service for President Ford in the next room, I was thinking of a side-bar listing called "Fallen Soldiers," but I think Lilalia's suggestion of "Forever Wise" is much nicer.
Keep the mementos. Sometimes we need that tangible link to our loved ones. If you haven't thrown them away by now, I'd say you need them.
Posted by: Buffy on Jan 3, 2007 5:30:37 PM
And here I thought I was the only one to do that....leave the names of those that passed on in my address book. Like you, I just can't bring myself to cross them out and I've had the same address book for almost 20 years. I find it comforting to leaf through it now and again just to bring back a few memories.
So...for the columnist, I'd leave him until his columns become obsolete to a visiting reader.
Posted by: Terri on Jan 3, 2007 7:41:09 PM
I hear you and have no advice to offer, but I want to thank you for introducing me to Donald Murray's writing.
Posted by: Wenda on Jan 3, 2007 7:54:27 PM
If Donald's writing touched you in the past it will no doubt do the same for others in the future. To deny the living the wisdom and poinancy of a gifted elder like Donald is to withold his most important legacy. I hope I'm not just saying this because I'm old, but I think almost everyone can leave some important insight to someone else. I think a memorial designation is very appropriate.
Posted by: goldenlucy on Jan 3, 2007 8:09:37 PM
There are plenty of suggestions here. Consider them, then follow your heart so that you will be at peace with your decision.
Mother passed last March. I kept her address book and her appointment calendar among other items. I feel blessed to have them.
:)
Posted by: Pooch on Jan 3, 2007 8:53:37 PM
"There were three items which, as my arm moved each toward the trash bag, I couldn’t part with....I don’t know why I can’t part with these three items ..." My dad died 2 years ago. I have a bedroom full of his stuff that I can't seem to clear out. When I stashed it there 2 yrs ago, I never dreamed I'd still have it. It's all old and odd and dusty and meaningful only to me because he loved it all. I think a lot about how I need to part with much of this stuff (old hats, swords, magazines, lamps, stools, baskets, crocks, chairs, letters). I don't want to keep a shrine to him, but then I say why not? It's an eyesore room but it IS an extra bedroom and my family (husband, 2 kids) don't complain. Glad I have a place to talk about this.
Posted by: Pam J. on Jan 3, 2007 9:50:11 PM
I can certainly identify with keeping items of departed loved ones -- my mother's, my husband's, letters and cards from others -- as I've previously commented.
I, too, have kept names and addresses of others no longer in my life in my current and old address books. I derive some small pleasure noting their names as I peruse the pages in search of others. Memories flash through my mind at the sight of the name, leaving me with warm feelings.
I think, like much of what you do, that you will arrive at a plan that feels most comfortable for now. Your choice does not have to be fixed for eternity, can evolve as time goes by (an unintentional but appropriate use of your blog name.) There are a number of good ideas and suggestions provided by others here.
Posted by: joared on Jan 3, 2007 11:17:03 PM
Lots of good suggestions here on this subject. Your dear mentor Mr. Murray it seems will be well remembered in his own right through his work. Certainly leaving his blog link here is a loving tribute in itself from one who admired his opinions and writings as you do.
Along the lines as suggested, you could set up a section on your blog like a “Memorial Page” and then when someone clicks on the link of a deceased friend’s site, they would be taken to the page where you could have a brief commentary or even photo of a person such as Mr. Murray and even additional links if appropriate. For others who were loyal visitors and acquaintances, you just have a brief entry that they were a loyal visitor and contributor to your blog over the years, etc, etc.
Speaking personally, there are those of us who have little to be remembered for so they can take solace in the hope that perhaps when we are dead and gone someone will leave our blog link on their site giving us a few more moments in the sun. So at the least, until they die, there will be a little dust still remaining.
Hmmmmm....does that sound like someone is feeling sorry for themselves or what? lol
Posted by: Alan G on Jan 4, 2007 9:40:47 AM
I read this yesterday and ended up in a sad and contemplative mood. I am unlike so many of your other commenters. I have framed pictures of my mother and father (now passed on) but I found I was too sad if they were hung on the wall. I don't need reminders to remember the spirit of those who I have lost. I may not remember the names of some friends, but I remember their spirit, how they touched my life, what I valued about them. I rip pages out of my address book and replace them. With people passing on like popcorn popping, I don't want reminders that extend my sorry. Cause today there may be another to add to the list.
I would rather have a comforting verse or poem. A thing applicable to every blogger that has left this world. A 23rd Psalm written specifically in honor of bloggers that have passed on and for the comfort of those who reman. Or a memorial like this one, (as someone stated), that you have fashioned and through it immortalized the best of your friend, Mr. Murray.
Posted by: Roberta S on Jan 4, 2007 11:20:18 AM
Ah, you can ruthlessly draw a coded line through his name. How heartless that seems. My heart was filled with good intentions this year, then they faded. I ended up putting the same old pages back in the book loathe to part with old friends even if they aren't here any more. Like you, I kept several of my mothers address books, and note they chronicle my own frequent moves.
Thank you, by the way, for all you do for all of us.
Posted by: Mage on Jan 4, 2007 10:47:21 PM
I find it difficult to remove phone numbers and addresses from my address book. I will miss Donald Murray's column as I read it everyweek and it still is in my Google reader list. Those columns are so full of wisdom...
Posted by: claude on Jan 5, 2007 4:20:30 PM








