« The Final Stretch of the Long Election Campaign | Main | Overriding Bush Veto to Save Original Medicare »

Tuesday, 26 August 2008

The Best Books on Aging

[EDITORIAL NOTE: Zoe Riley, who blogs at Journeys Through Time, has joined the Quarterstaff Revolution. Is there anyone else out there with a photograph of themselves with their staff? If so, please do send it in.]

There are thousands of books about getting old and sometimes I feel as though I’ve read them all – painfully in cases when they are about how to pretend you are still young or are filled with bad jokes or with treacle enough to turn your gills green.

There are, however, a few I consider essential – informative, inspiring and wise, each in its own way:

What Are Old People For?
By Dr. William H. Thomas who contributes bi-weekly columns on this blog as The TGB Geriatrician.

Why Survive? Being Old in America
By Dr. Robert N. Butler who coined the term “ageism.” This book, published in 1975, won the Pulitzer Prize.

The Longevity Revolution
Also by Dr. Robert N. Butler. He gave TGB an excellent interview about this new book last April.

The Fountain of Age
By the mother of modern feminism, Betty Friedan, published in 1993. Hard going to read, but rewarding for the effort.

The Summer of a Dormouse
By British playwright, novelist and barrister, John Mortimer, who is also the author of the Rumpole of the Bailey series of stories.

From Age-ing to Sage-ing
By Rabbi Zalman Schachter-Shalomi published in 1997.

Journal of a Solitude by May Sarton. Secondarily, these two by her: At Seventy: A Journal and Encore: A Journal of the Eightieth Year

Of course, there are others that are good, but these rise so far above the ordinary that I consider them my personal guides to getting old. I often peruse sections of them at random and am never disappointed.

In a recent email, Camille Shaffer, who has contributed some stories to The Elder Storytelling Place, reminded me of another book, The Last Gift of Time: Life Beyond Sixty by Carolyn G. Heilbrun which I’ve allowed to sit on the shelf for too long. You might know Ms. Heilbrun by her mystery-writing pseudonym, Amanda Cross.

I don’t agree with some of Ms. Heilbrun’s observations about getting old, but that doesn’t make her book less thoughtful and important. Camille picked out some quotes to include in her email that sang to her and may inspire you:

“I have become more physically settled in my sixties, liking to be home, or toggling from one home to the next. Routine, which I used to scorn as next door to incarceration, holds new appeal for me. But one must not sit and think and ruminate all day.”
“Our sixties give us the chance to get out, not only from a job but from much else that we have been doing unquestioningly for a long time.”
The point is only that for those retired, with too much time and no world, a world must be found, and not necessarily one that is heavily populated. One can join a group or work alone; the essential is that the work be difficult, concentrated, and that definite progress can be measured. If the undertaking is not to become another daily habit, daily donned and discarded, it requires strong effort and the evidence of growing proficiency.”
“…it is our very presence that is important to the young. They want us to be there: not in their homes, perhaps, not watching them with a baleful eye as they go about their daily work, but there. We reassure them that life continues, and if we listen, we assure them that it matters to us that it continues.”
“Aging, particularly in the later decades, is a drawing in. Encounters with the outside world diminish for many reasons. The solitude of old age is often pleasurable. There is peace, a sense of the present.”

As the media has caught on to the fact that the gigantic generation of baby boomers is beginning to enter late life, they have rushed to cash in with a plethora of books about getting old, and there will only be more in the years to come. Most are quick hits with no intention to value or thoughtfulness, so superficial they float up off the table.

But you cannot go wrong with any of the ones above.

(NOTE 1: I have created a new section for this book list which is permanently available from the right sidebar under TGB Features. I will update this from time to time with any new (or new to me), good books I discover. There are also a few representative quotations from the books.)

(NOTE 2: The book links above go to the books' pages at amazon.com. If you choose to buy any and use these links to do so, I will receive a small commission.)

[At The Elder Storytelling Place today, Sharon McKinney gives us a School Tale which is not what you would immediately think it is.]

Posted by Ronni Bennett at 05:32 AM | Permalink | Email this post

Comments

Ronni had to smile as I read your post this morning. I have read all of the books you have mentioned except "The Summer of a Dormouse". "The Fountain of Age" read several times. May Sarton's books were recommended to me by my son.
The last two quotes seemed to be the most meaningful to me.

Posted by: Ernestine on Aug 26, 2008 6:41:04 AM

I had Carolyn Heilbrun's book on my own favourites list for a long time too as I was inspired by her vision of how one's sixties might be.
But now, at 72, looking back at it, I am not sure she was completely 'on message'. Not for me, at any rate.
Yes, I agree about the 'drawing-in', the delight in solitude, the ability to stay more in a peaceful present. As an introvert, that feels good to me. I think we all - especially women - need encouraging to be more self-directed in the second half of our lives and Heilbrun's book did that well. It helped me to get a better balance between caring for others and caring for self.
But to commit suicide at 77, with just one, generic, seven-word note for all who cared about her seemed to me like a really selfish thing for Heilbrun to do. It was a step too far, IMO.
Much as I believe in a person's right to end his or her own life, and much as I revel in solitude, autonomy and inner-directedness, there is something that feels narcissistic about these when they totally outweigh relationship - relationship with family, friends, community, society, the Earth.
Maybe I'm wrong and in another five years I'll be putting a plastic bag over my head too. But I very much doubt it.

Posted by: Marian Van Eyk McCain on Aug 26, 2008 8:34:45 AM

I agree. Heilbrun spoiled it with her suicide. No one can know what drives another person to that point. (Depression, obviously.) But it's such a cruel thing to do to the people who love you and those who look to you for inspiration.

I would add Florida Scott-Maxwell to the list. Can't come up with a title just now, but I remember reading her in my 20s and being very struck by her description of the fieriness of the 80s.

Posted by: on Aug 26, 2008 10:17:34 AM

Florida Scott-Maxwell's "The Measure of My Days" has rested near my computer for a long time. Read in fits and starts some time ago, I thank commenter "on" for reminding me about it. Much to consider.

Posted by: naomi dagen bloom on Aug 26, 2008 11:45:51 AM

I haven't read Heilbrun's non-fiction. I have put the one book our local library has on my list for my next visit. I have long thought that three of her Kate Fansler books made interesting statements about aging and women. 'Sweet Death, Kind Death' (especially considering her suicide), 'No Word From Winifred,' and 'The Players Come Again,' all contain interesting portrayals of older women who are very definite individuals with their own agendas and goals. I think they are among the most positive views I have read, fictional or otherwise. I agree with you about Friedan's 'Fountain of Age.' I have read it twice and both times it required effort and was well worth the effort.

Posted by: Mary Walker on Aug 26, 2008 12:44:08 PM

Why is suicide @ 77 so bad? Maybe after a good and full life, the prospect of a slow decline into impotence, immobility and senility offers no real appeal. Maybe it's better to go out with strength and dignity than weakness and fear. "Society", that faceless monster that wants to rule every aspect of our lives in conjunction with its partners "Apathy" and "conformity" says that we should wait til death decides it's time rather than making the decision ourselves but personally I think "Society", like "Everybody", is a poor source of meaningful information.
"Viva la muerte!"

Posted by: mythster on Aug 26, 2008 4:46:07 PM

Very nice assembly, Ronni! It struck me reading the comments that it might be fun to also list/compare/discuss characters in literature who really demonstrate the 'truth'(s) of ageing...and maybe good portrayals from short stories/folks tales we might all access easily!

Hmmmm...who would be your favorites? Maybe we could 'do' categories: children's books, tweenagers, esp. for women, mothers, shorter versus long, longer lived, etc.

Realistic or symbolic, these characterizations out there in the cultural mindset would be fun to share and compare...then compare with those in another country!

Posted by: Kathi on Aug 26, 2008 6:18:47 PM

Some other suggestions:
Eda LeShan, It's Better to Be Over the Hill Than Under It,
"...no starry-eyed paean to the 'golden years.' [It is a] guide to turning what Cicero called 'our play's last act' into a thing that merits some appaluse." (N.Y. Times Book Review)

Mary C. Morrison, "Let Evening Come: Reflections on Aging". Short, easy reading. Observations of a fascinating woman who has lived a full life and has learned how to enjoy old age.

Christopher Matthew, "Now We Are Sixty" has taken some of A.A. Milne's best loved poems and rewritten them for 60-year olds.

So many books, so little time!

Posted by: Nana Royer on Aug 26, 2008 7:22:23 PM

Ronni, you have done it again, and in a big way this time. With all these interesting books to read, when can I ever get over tired lips and ink-stained forefinger?

Kathi has a good idea. There are so many favorite characters who "demonstrate the truths of aging" in literature. It would be a pleasure to list them!

Posted by: Mike Nichols on Aug 26, 2008 7:24:07 PM

I liked Lillian Rubin's "60 on Up," Nora Ephron's "I Feel Bad About My Neck," and "The Denial of Aging: Perpetual Youth, Eternal Life, and Other Dangerous Fantasies" by Muriel R. Gillick.

Posted by: Paula on Aug 26, 2008 7:59:33 PM

I leapt upon May Sarton's books when I first discovered them then was frozen a bit by her depressions. When I cleaned out my bookcases before the move, I kept all her books. I'm always glad I did.

And look what you have done. Stirred things up again. Delightfully.

Posted by: Mage B on Aug 26, 2008 9:27:54 PM

I read some Amanda Cross mysteries and was not aware that the author had committed suicide. My father did the same at age 65 and frankly I'm conflicted about it. My sons and I, who adored him, took it hard. It left my mother widowed in her 50s. Yet I can understand his wanting to avoid the terrible agonizing decline that, in fact, she experienced until her death at 90. Hers was not a happyt elderhood. I feel I'd like to copy and post Heilbrun's "a world mustbe found" quote. I'm struggling with that right now. Yet a part of me wonders if in elderhood it isn't time to just be without worrying what we are going to "do" in the world.

Posted by: Audrey Vest on Aug 27, 2008 12:30:12 PM

Sixty? My oldest son is 63, and at 82 I'm way past seeing the 60's as "old."

Does anyone but me lovingly detail their bowel movements in journal entries, or are those of interest only to those of us with gut diseases? (I'm a Crohns victim.)

Sometimes I wake thinking it would be a good idea to off myself--but the idea fades as the day gets more interesting.

Oh, and I'm still so computer ignorant: what's a URL?

Posted by: Mimi Merrill on Aug 27, 2008 4:05:42 PM


Post a comment