How the Romney-Ryan Ticket Affects Elders

ELDER MUSIC: Summertime

PeterTibbles75x75This Sunday Elder Music column was launched in December of 2008. By May of the following year, one commenter, Peter Tibbles, had added so much knowledge and value to my poor attempts at musical presentations that I asked him to take over the column. He's been here each week ever since delighting us with his astonishing grasp of just about everything musical, his humor and sense of fun. You can read Peter's bio here and find links to all his columns here.

category_bug_eldermusic It’s time for another variation on a single song and the one today is Summertime. This was from the opera “Porgy and Bess” by George Gershwin. The lyrics weren’t by his brother Ira, who wrote them for most of George’s songs, but by DuBois Heyward upon whose novel, Porgy, the opera is based.

The song pretty soon became a standard and entered the lexicon of popular and jazz singers. We’ll have some of them today as well as a couple of interesting instrumental versions.Also one or two that I hope will surprise you.

According to Wikipedia, it’s the most covered song in history and there are more than 25,000 recorded versions out there. Not all of those will be present today.

We might as well start with the best, BILLIE HOLIDAY.

Billie Holiday

It sounds as if Billie was born to sing this song. Of course, she sounded as if she was born to sing anything she tackled. Hers was the first version to make the charts, back in 1936. She has Count Basie and his band backing her on this one.

♫ Billie Holiday - Summertime

It was a tossup between LOU RAWLS and Johnny Hartman for this spot. Lou called heads.

Lou Rawls

Lou started out as a gospel singer and while still a boy he sang with Sam Cooke, who wasn’t much older than Lou, in a gospel group. He also met and sang with Curtis Mayfield around the same time.

Over the years Lou has sung gospel, soul and R&B music but he was always essentially a jazz singer as is amply demonstrated on his version of Summertime.

♫ Lou Rawls - Summertime

BILL EVANS was one of the best jazz pianists. This assessment of his abilities was shared by Miles Davis who requested that he join (or rejoin, really) him to record the “Kind of Blue” album.

Bill Evans

Bill was classically trained; he started lessons on the piano when he was only six. He was also proficient on the flute and violin.

He rebelled against the restrictions of classical music – he wasn’t allowed to improvise so he switched to jazz in his early teenage years and started playing professionally before he was 20. Unfortunately, he had a long-time problem with drugs and he died at age 51.

♫ Bill Evans - Summertime

To give us a rock & roll perspective on the song here’s Janis Joplin in front of BIG BROTHER AND THE HOLDING COMPANY.

Big Brother and the Holding Company

This was a regular inclusion in their live sets and appeared on their most famous album “Cheap Thrills”. Instead of that one here’s the song from a live album of theirs “Live at The Carousel Ballroom,” recorded in 1968.

The two versions are quite similar and this one gives a flavor of their live performance.

♫ Big Brother and the Holding Company - Summertime

SAM COOKE could make any song sound perfect, or nearly so in this case.

Sam Cooke

However, he really didn’t need that chorus behind him, adding nothing at all to the song. I guess they did that sort of thing back then. Fortunately, they aren’t too intrusive.

Sam’s version sounds to me like a soul song interpreted as a country tune.

♫ Sam Cooke - Summertime

LAMBERT, HENDRICKS AND ROSS have the shortest version of the song and maybe the most interesting.

Lambert, Hendricks and Ross

As was often the case when LH&R interpreted a song, they took it and ran with it taking it to places no one had gone before. That certainly happened this time.

LH&R’s career wasn’t very long, only about five years. Annie Ross first left the group and not too long afterwards, Dave Lambert was killed in a car accident. Jon Hendricks and Annie Ross are still with us as of this writing and occasionally perform together.

♫ Lambert, Hendricks and Ross - Summertime

The version that reached the highest spot on the charts is by BILLY STEWART.

Billy Stewart

This one always brings a smile to my face as it’s so outrageous, although following that one by LH&R it may not seem so.

Billy won a local (Washington D.C.) talent contest with his version of our song. He had honed his singing in his mother’s gospel group, The Stewart Gospel Singers. Bo Diddley heard him and hired Billy to play piano in his group. He eventually got Billy a recording contract and Summertime was one of his first releases.

♫ Billy Stewart - Summertime

MILES DAVIS recorded an entire album of “Porgy and Bess” music.

Miles Davis

I used him on a previous column dedicated to “Porgy and Bess” where, fortunately, I featured It Ain't Necessarily So from Miles so I won’t be doubling up. This is his version of Summertime.

♫ Miles Davis - Summertime

There have been several different versions of THE DRIFTERS. The two most notable ones were fronted by Clyde McPhatter and Ben E. King.

The Drifters

I listened closely to this version and I’m pretty sure it was neither of those singing lead. The CD is no help at all and nor is Dr. Google. Besides the “official” Drifters, there were others who used the name and as far as I can tell this is one of those.

I think it’s a group purporting to be The Drifters and is fronted by Matthew Child. Whoever he is, he’s a pretty fine singer.

♫ The Drifters - Summertime

I thought I was familiar with RICKY NELSON's music but this surprised me. It shouldn’t have as it’s on one of my CDs, so there you go.

Ricky Nelson

It was the done thing back when Ricky was first recording that singers should become “all round entertainers” after a year or two in the rock & roll sun. Some resisted this pressure but others, like Ricky, recorded standards along with their usual songs.

Here is Ricky being an all round entertainer (sort of – this isn’t quite as all round as some other songs).

♫ Ricky Nelson - Summertime

Just missing the cut are versions by Johnny Hartman, Judy Garland, Kenny Burrell, Paul Robeson, Stan Getz, Peggy Lee and also a few other lesser known performers.


I have tried for years to find a copy of the movie "Porgy and Bess" starring Sidney Poitier, Sammy Davis, Jr., Dorothy Dandridge, etal. Any idea where I can find one?

I have heard a rumor that Mr. Poitier bought the rights to the movie and will not release it because it is "demeaning to blacks." Any truth to that, do you think? I love the music and would love to see the movie again.

Class of 65:

According to Wikipedia, it was removed by the Gershwin estate:

Such fun! I always enjoy your music posts, Peter. Thank you.

Glad you didn't leave out the ultimate version of Summertime, Tibs - has to be Billy Stewart's!!

I guess the better music survives the test of time when musicians of several generations like it well enough to give their interpretations -- or their record label told them to add it because it would be marketable -- as musicians have often complained was done back in the day.

Probably the musicians, musical arrangement versions we enjoy the most are those that come from each of our respective generations with lap-overs to some older and newer musicians. That said, as much as I revere Billie Holiday as a jazz force and enjoy a few of her tunes, I think other jazz vocalists (some who even defer to Holiday) deliver a much richer interpretation of this song -- but that's just my personal bias. Ella F.'s various interpretations cannot be surpassed.

I enjoy the instrumental selections of Bill Evans and Miles Davis you have here.

I appreciate much music from Lambert, Hendricks and Ross, particularly their influence on other groups, but their version of Summertime is not what I would consider one of their better arrangements. I always regretted their career as a group was so short.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)