INTERESTING STUFF: 17 November 2012
Uncluttering Seven Decades of Life

ELDER MUSIC: Beethoven Again

PeterTibbles75x75This Sunday Elder Music column was launched in December of 2008. By May of the following year, one commenter, Peter Tibbles, had added so much knowledge and value to my poor attempts at musical presentations that I asked him to take over the column. He's been here each week ever since delighting us with his astonishing grasp of just about everything musical, his humor and sense of fun. You can read Peter's bio here and find links to all his columns here.

category_bug_eldermusic I’ve featured Beethoven before but today I thought I’d highlight some rather unusual music from him. These are interesting - well interesting to me. You may be surprised by several of them.

Okay, maybe you won’t, but I certainly was. I was looking through my Beethoven box – that’s the complete work of the composer, there’s still some I haven’t played yet – and I came across these. I thought they could make a different column and wondered what else lurks within.

So I went searching and came up with the music for the column. There are pieces I knew already but others were a revelation. I found too many so there could be another column.


I’ll start with a very odd piece of music indeed. It begins quietly and is like that for about a minute so there’s nothing wrong with your computer (okay, I suppose there could be something wrong with it but don’t blame the music).

There are also lots of strange sound effects. These were on the CD but it isn’t someone like Spike Jones taking the mickey; this is for real, folks. It’s called Wellington's Victory or The Battle of Victoria. I guess they liked alternate titles back then.

It’s performed by Neville Mariner conducting the Academy of St Martin-in-the-Fields. There may also be something in there you’ll recognize. It sounds to me like the soundtrack for a very odd war movie.

If you thought Tchaikovsky first thought of using cannons in music, Ludwig beat him by about sixty years. In fact, you’d better duck your head, there’s so much fire power in this one.

♫ Wellington's Victory or the Battle of Victoria, Op. 91

Now for something completely different, something a little more conventional and a lot shorter, only 42 seconds long. Short is something else generally not associated with Ludwig.

Indeed, the title is longer than the piece itself. It’s Variations on “See the Conqu'ring Hero Comes” From Handel's Judas Maccabeus - Variation 1.

♫ 12 Variations on See the Conqu'ring Hero comes from Handel's Judas Maccabeus - Variation 1

That was so short we might as well have another one. This is Variation 2.

♫ 12 Variations on See the Conqu'ring Hero comes from Handel's Judas Maccabeus - Variation 2

There are twelve in all but I’ll quit while I’m ahead.

George Thomson was a publisher and collector of folk songs in the late 18th and early 19th centuries. He got composers of the day to set these to music and paid them really well.

Ludwig was certainly up for this - after all, money was involved. He set dozens of Welsh, English, Scottish and Irish songs to his music. Later, he did the same with a number of European songs as well but George wasn’t involved in that enterprise.

Here is one of the Irish songs, The Elfin Fairies, sung by Barbara Schedel and Kerstin Wagner.

♫ The Elfin Fairies

The flute isn’t an instrument you normally think of when Ludwig’s name is mentioned. This is a piece I considered for my column on flutes but decided it should appear here.

This has the great Jean-Pierre Rampal fluting away with Christian Larde and Alain Marion playing along with him. It’s the trio in G Major for 3 flutes and is subtitled Spurious” for some reason.

♫ Trio pour 3 flutes en Sol Majeur Spurious - I. Allegro

Ludwig wrote a whole bunch of dances but they’re all really short. I guess they didn’t have much stamina back then or a really short attention span. Here are a couple of them. This first is taken from a set of 12 Contredanses for Small Orchestra. It’s No. 1.

♫ 12 Contredanses pour Petit Orchestre, WoO14 - No.01 en Do Majeur

The next is from a different set of dances, this time from a group of 11, mainly for woodwind instruments. I really like this one, it’s also No. 1. It’s a Dance for 7 String and Wind Instruments.

♫ 11 danses pour 7 cordes & instruments à vent, WoO17 - No.01 Valse en Mi Bémol Majeur


Something a little more conventional. Here is the first movement from the String Quartet in B flat major Op. 18 No. 6. It’s a really sunny sort of work - however, not simple. It can stand repeated playing without losing its charm as I found while preparing this.

♫ String Quartet in B flat major Op. 18 No. 6 (1)

Back to the woodwinds. Ludwig wrote quite a number of works for various forms of wind ensembles, including three for duos of clarinet and bassoon. This is the first movement of the Duo clarinet and bassoon, No 1 in C major.

♫ Duos for clarinet & bassoon, WoO27 No.1 in C Major (1)

Another really nice, and short, work for woodwinds, and a couple of French horns as well. The March for 2 Clarinets, 2 Horns & 2 Bassoons in B Flat Major, WoO29.

♫ March for 2 clarinets, 2 horns & 2 bassoons in B Flat Major, WoO29

Ludwig’s piano sonatas are about the best things written for a solo piano. These are major works and aren’t really suited to the column today. Instead, here are some piano pieces that are nowhere near as long or as intricate as those others.

These are generally considered dances and I can see folks tripping the light fantastic to them. There are several CDs of them but I’ve chosen three from a series called Deutsche Tänze. The first of these is Dance No. 3.

♫ 12 Deutsche Tänze, WoO13 - No.03 en SolMajeur

Next is Dance No. 7.

♫ 12 Deutsche Tänze, WoO13 - No.07 en Ré Majeur

Finally, Dance No. 10.

♫ 12 Deutsche Tänze, WoO13 - No.10 en Do Majeur



When Leonard Bernstein appeared at Harvard for a series of lectures on music, "The Unanswered Question," he talked about another of Beethoven's compositions, I believe, that began with birdsong. He was asking students to look past the obvious sound effects to study the construction of the piece, the grammar of it. I think I'd have to be looking at the sheet music and not hearing it to listen beyond the sound effects in the first example you included. I just don't know enough about music to do it otherwise! Wish I did. Bernstein's series from the early 1970's, available free at Open Culture, was a bit over my head, but I so enjoyed it.

I'm a serious Beethoven fan but don't have Tibble's complete disocography and surely haven't heard everything. I enjoyed this post very much. I wonder about the pictures, they are also new to me. I'm curious if any were done in his lifetime. The ones I'm familiar with are "wilder"-- emphasizing his angst and all the drama. The youthful one is utterly different.

Sorry June, I don’t know. I just go on Google Images for likely pictures.

What happened to the comment I made yesterday? I must have forgotten to post it after previewing it. If you are still reading comments I wanted to thank you for this post. I love Beethoven and have a special connection with him due to having the same disability.

I listened to all of the recordings and have to tell you that the Wellington's Victory really sounded like music. When the violins, flutes and clarinets were carrying the melodies on most of the other pieces I was unable to distinguish the tones. This will be invaluable information to give my audiologist when I get a new mapping (adjusting the electrodes in my Ci).

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)