Of a Holiday, Contest Winners and a Favorite Elder


Tibbles1SM100x130This Sunday Elder Music column was launched in December of 2008. By May of the following year, one commenter, Peter Tibbles, had added so much knowledge and value to my poor attempts at musical presentations that I asked him to take over the column. He's been here each week ever since delighting us with his astonishing grasp of just about everything musical, his humor and sense of fun. You can read Peter's bio here and find links to all his columns here.

What happened in 1947?

  • Tim Buckley was born
  • A Streetcar Named Desire premiered on Broadway
  • Edwin Land demonstrated the Polaroid camera
  • A weather balloon crashed at Roswell, New Mexico
  • "The Paradine Case was released
  • America won the Davis Cup
  • Carlton were premiers.

ROY BROWN recorded Good Rockin' Tonight after offering it to Wynonie Harris who turned it down.

Roy Brown

After Roy's version became a hit, Wynonie recorded it after all, making it more energetic. It became a bigger hit than Roy's but he didn't mind as he collected the royalties.

It was later memorably covered by Elvis and others including Pat Boone (cringe).

♫ Roy Brown - Good Rockin' Tonight

CHARLES TRENET didn't perform any songs he didn't write himself.

Charles Trenet

Fortunately, he was a prolific tunesmith, way over a thousand, so there were enough that he wouldn't have to wonder what to do next. Certainly the most famous of his songs in the English-speaking world is La Mer.

♫ Charles Trenet - La Mer

Now for the great T-BONE WALKER with his song, Call It Stormy Monday (But Tuesday Is Just As Bad).

T-Bone Walker

That's the official title of the song. It's usually just called Stormy Monday but there are other songs with that title. Given all that, this is by far the best known of them so there's generally no confusion (unless we're playing one of the others).

♫ T-Bone Walker - Stormy Monday

Next up, FRANK SINATRA with one of his memorable songs. Okay, that doesn't narrow it down too much.

Frank Sinatra

This is September Song, written by Kurt Weill and Maxwell Anderson supplied the lyrics. The song was written especially for Walter Huston, of all people, to sing in the film, Knickerbocker Holiday.

Frank recorded this song a couple more times, not counting live albums, of course, but here is the one recorded in 1947.

♫ Frank Sinatra - September Song

Now the man we have to thank/blame (take your pick) for rock & roll. Without him, it's possible it wouldn't have happened, certainly not the same way. I'm talking, of course, of BIG JOE TURNER.

Big Joe Turner

Even in these songs of his from the forties we have a taste of what was to come. This is My Gal's a Jockey.

♫ Big Joe Turner - My Gal's a Jockey

THE MILLS BROTHERS certainly kept on keeping on.

The Mills Brothers

Although they started singing around the house earlier and at their father's barbershop (making them a barbershop quartet, I guess), they began professionally in 1926. Unfortunately, one brother (John) died 10 years later.

They contemplated breaking up but dad (also John) stepped in to take his place. After celebrating their 50th year in show biz, dad left due to various medical complications.

They carried on as a trio. Harry died in 1982 (that's 56 years by now) and Herbert and Donald kept going until Herbert died in 1989 (63 years in the business). At this stage John III, Donald's son, joined up.

They kept going until Donald died in 1999 (that brings us to 73 years performing). Young John continues the tradition going with a bit of outside help.

Here they are with Across the Alley from the Alamo.

♫ The Mills Brothers - Across The Alley From The Alamo

American universities certainly indulge in some strange practices: in too many of them the overwhelming emphasis on sport rather than learning springs immediately to mind. Then there are fraternities and sororities. What are you thinking of?

That brings me to the Whiffenpoofs who at least seem to be just a choral group (at Yale). They have their own song, Whiffenpoof Song. Here's BING CROSBY to sing it.

Bing Crosby

♫ Bing Crosby - Whiffenpoof Song

Open the Door, Richard started out as a black vaudeville routine. The performer half spoke, half sang the refrain. It was turned into a song by Jack McVea who generally played saxophone.

It was such a runaway success that more than a dozen other versions were recorded, many of them were also hits. Here is one of them by LOUIS JORDAN.

Louis Jordan

♫ Louis Jordan - Open the Door, Richard

Golden Earrings was a spy film from this year with Ray Milland. The song was sung in the film by Murvyn Vye, who is new to me. This was quite popular so folks were lining up to record it.

Bing was first out of the starting blocks, but the big hit was by PEGGY LEE.

Peggy Lee

♫ Peggy Lee - Golden Earrings


Hank Williams

The song Move It on Over, Hank's first hit, like some other songs this year, presages rock & roll. It sounds like pure country but the structure is really that of a blues song.

The solo guitar would not sound out of place in any later rock song.

♫ Hank Williams - Move It on Over

1948 will appear in two weeks' time.


What an eclectic array of musical styles this morning. I'm putting these all on my tablet. Great job as usual Peter.

I think that September Song will be my theme song from now on. Those precious days are here now and are getting fewer. I don't think anybody sang it better than Frankie; certainly not Walter Brennan.

I had forgotten what a really mellow voice Bing had. I had to sing the Whiffenpoof song in my head before I was able to pick out the melody. Darned Cochlear Implant.

....and ahhhhhhhhh, Peggy Lee! And yes, that's all there Dee

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)