Guest Blogger: Claude Covo-Farchi
Friday, 24 March 2006
[EDITORIAL NOTE: While I'm in Maine this week, several elderbloggers agreed to substitute for me. Today, Claude Covo-Farchi of Blogging in Paris writes of her mother’s last days, and of facing her own mortality. Please welcome her to Time Goes By and visit her blog too.]
Ronni Bennett has asked me to write a piece for Time Goes By as a guest blogger, which thrills me, but which I also find a bit frightening, considering English is not my mother tongue.
For a long time, I have been thinking about the way my mother died. Gitta lived some fifty years with Joseph, her husband, and for the last years of her husband's life, all her energies were turned towards taking care of him. Joseph had a heart condition and she did everything she could to keep him healthy. She behaved like a real Jewish mother to him.
So much so that sometimes, it even got on his nerves! When I visited, he suggested going for a walk with me, and in fact we would go to the café around the corner and talk over a cup of coffee.
When he died in 1982, Gitta felt totally useless and all the health problems that had been masked before his death started manifesting. She had been a heavy smoker all her life, and had only quit smoking in 1976. To Gitta, your body was like a car. If you were sick, you went to the doctor’s and told him where the pain was, and like a garage mechanic, he'd fix it. But emphyzema couldn't be fixed and although she ignored it while my father was alive, it started showing and growing after his death.
I visited several times a week and, weather permitting, we would go out for a walk. Her breath was so short that I had to carry a small stool along, and she would sit every five minutes to catch her breath. Soon, she needed oxygen, and we couldn't even do that.
I remember one time when I had to take her to hospital, which fortunately was across the street from where I then lived. She had to stay there for quite a while and started losing her bearings. Once, she told me how my sister-in-law had misplaced her plates –she thought she was still at home. One afternoon, she told me how she had seen German soldiers come and take a baby from the hospital during the night.
To hospital staff, her mind was perfectly all right, as some of the time, she made sense. Well, indeed she had not totally lost her mind, but she was lost in a place she didn't know.
Eventually, when she went back home, after a couple of weeks, she was back to her old self, at least mentally. But her strength was declining and eventually, she had to accept that she couldn't remain at home on her own.
This was really hard for her to accept. You see, Gitta had always been a very capable woman. Not submissive, not patient, not the sort of woman who could accept losing her independence easily.
Of course, writing about my mother's death brings to my mind the way I am going to grow older and die. It is difficult, almost impossible to imagine losing my independence. Since my husband's death, I have become quite a loner. I have a good many friends whose company I enjoy, but mostly, I do what I like when I like and have become a pretty independent woman.
And it's even more difficult to imagine feeling my body wane, my legs weaken and not carry me through long walks any more.
Through my experience of seeing Gitta or other members of my family who passed away, I feel that I should get my mind used to the idea that there will be a time in my life when I will need help. But I find it difficult to write about it. Or is it just hard to think about it?
When I started this piece, I had planned a short part about my mother and a longer part trying to reflect about the future. But somehow, my mind refuses to go there. I will cross those bridges when I come to them, no doubt, as I have crossed others, but it irks me to realise what a coward I am.
Facing death is never going to be easy for any of us. I reflect often on the deaths of my parents and wonder even now if I could have done more for them. It is fruitless of course, what is done is done, but we always think and remember.
Posted by: ian | Friday, 24 March 2006 at 02:41 AM
I think we become more aware of our preparations for death as we grow older. I imagine that death accompanies us throughout life but just becomes more conscious as we grow nearer to it. Sometimes I truly fear that helplessness, as you describe here. Sometimes I cannot even imagine not being here anymore. It is truly one of life's challenges. But as Billy Crystal says in "City Slickers," "We'll jump off that bridge when we come to it."
Beautiful post, Claude [if *only* I could write as well in French!]
Posted by: Tamar | Friday, 24 March 2006 at 02:54 AM
I guess one of the things parents give us comes towards the end of life, instead of at the beginning as I formerly thought. It is the power of example. My husband's going through it now: his mother - like yours, Claude - smoked till late in life, and thus has emphyzema. This curtails her activity, so her hips and legs are frailer and frailer from lack of exercise. It's now a big production for her to even go out of her apartment for a meal (at 85).
My husband stopped smoking in his early thirties, and now - watching his mother - he cleaves to his daily exercise program to try to keep his lungs, heart, and legs strong. So in a convoluted, unanticipated, and sad way, our parents are still teaching us.
Posted by: ml | Friday, 24 March 2006 at 04:42 AM
Well done, Claude. I wish it wasn't that way, but each of us must face death in our own way, in our own time.
Posted by: Milt | Friday, 24 March 2006 at 06:33 AM
Claude, this is a wonderful post...and one I relate VERY much to. My mother has the same health issues that your mother did. We are at the same crossroads with her right now. And, I feel very similar to what you're feeling about my own health waning away...and writing about it. We've both lost our husbands, and we're figuring out what we're all about. Amazing!
Posted by: Joy | Friday, 24 March 2006 at 07:39 AM
No Claude, never a coward. You are invested in the present in so vital and intimate a fashion you don't have the time to worry about "the future." I think that takes the most courage of all.
There were many years I did nothing but fret about "the future"---mostly mine but the world in general too. This did not bring me peace nor make me happy.
A few years ago I made the decision to live simply and simply live every day. That's tough for me to do but I'm committed to staying "in the moment"--and to being grateful for every one. I don't know how I'll "end up" but I'm just appreciating (if not enjoying) every day getting there.
Claude, no matter what the earthly future holds, your curiousity, vitality and compassionate humanity will certainly spell a life well lived. I'm feel blessed to have shared at bit of it!
A week of peace, my friend.
lucyd
Posted by: goldenlucyd | Friday, 24 March 2006 at 08:31 AM
Oh, and Joy, your post today was such an inspiration and delight...and for me it segued right Claude's. Thanks to both of you!
lucyd
Posted by: goldenlucyd | Friday, 24 March 2006 at 08:35 AM
Claude,
Even after four years of high school French, there is no way I could measure up to your skill of translation.
My dad passed away from complications of advanced emphysema and lung cancer and my mother now has moderate stage emphysema. She is convinced she can "cure" it with sheer willpower and well she might.
TGB has become the best blog on earth to visit and you are part of that recipe, Claude. Thanks!
Posted by: Cowtown Pattie | Friday, 24 March 2006 at 09:39 AM
Claude; Thanks for filling in for Ronni in such a meaningful way.
.
I wonder why it is when we are younger we do not generally fret about our own death or disability. None of us are sure of even one day of life or good health no matter our age. I don't have any answers but I do know I pray I am never a burden for my family. I suppose we just have to play the hands we are dealt.
----------------------------
I know one thing that keeps me "young". It is my sweet young grand children.
We went out for dinner last night for son's 41st birthday. 7 year old Grandson Harrison was sitting next to me.He leaned into me and asked
" Bebe, How old did you say you are?"
Are you 76?"
Teasingly I answered
"Harrison, sometimes I forget whether I am 76 or 67"
Harrrison smiled and said
" Well, Bebe I know you can NOT BE PAST 70 so you MUST be 67."
I laughed and said
" Why, thank you that is sweet but I AM 76."
Harrison said
"Well Bebe, You are MUCH YOUNGER than that to me. You look young"
"I smiled and hugged him and said " You Sweet Boy. It is fine young grand children like you who keep me "YOUNG".
Such a smoozer...lol
Posted by: Chancy | Friday, 24 March 2006 at 10:51 AM
Claude, your guest post touched me deeply. I suppose like many independent people (I was going to say "women" but it goes for men too), I dread losing control: of my body, of my mind, of my time, of my surroundings, to the extent that I have it now. We all need to take a big lesson from goldenlucyd: "simply" live every day...as if it were simple! Acceptance seems to spread joy.
Posted by: savtadotty | Friday, 24 March 2006 at 11:32 AM
Reading your post reminded me of the time my mother was in the hospital and thought she was in her kitchen and asked me to get something out of the cabinet. It was a frightning experience. Later I learned that is not unusual for an elderly person in an unfamiliar place and under medication. If only a nurse or doctor would take the time to explain that to the family.
I have always admired your photos, they paint such vivid pictures and now you just did it with words.
Posted by: Millie Garfield | Friday, 24 March 2006 at 01:11 PM
Claude... pronounced cl-oh-d, cl-long "o"-d, clohd, Claude has long been one of my favorite names. here in the US we tend to pronounce it like the past tense of what the cat did to the table legs... "clawed." But Claude is ever so pretty.
I enjoyed your post too, of course.
Posted by: fp | Friday, 24 March 2006 at 07:34 PM
Thought the content of what you wrote was very moving. Seems so many times we muster the strength to care for a loved one, then, when they're gone we suddenly let down whatever it was that kept us going and face our own challenges.
Also, couldn't help noting with what little writing I have done here that I, too, start writing in one direction and then find myself somewhere else.
I think, too, there are times when we're better suited to staying in the present moment than reflecting on the future.
Posted by: joared | Friday, 24 March 2006 at 11:38 PM
Thanks everyone for your kind comments. I am moved and thrilled by your response and will reply as soon as I get home, and can use my usual keyboard. Am fighting with apostrophes and letters being where they shouldn't be ;)
Posted by: Claude | Saturday, 25 March 2006 at 10:01 AM
"There comes a time in your life when most of the places you go to you will never go back to, and nearly all the books in your shelves you will never read again."
Clive James, "Knight, Death, the Devil and Peter Porter".
Posted by: Guest | Wednesday, 07 March 2007 at 06:54 AM
un peu court mais pas mal du tout
Posted by: Fryderyk | Friday, 01 June 2007 at 03:10 AM