Crabby Old Lady Wonders…
Why Death is Important to the Future

Medicare Fraud

category_bug_journal2.gif Yesterday, the San Diego Union Tribune reported that three people have been charged with Medicare fraud and identity theft to the tune of $1.3 million. The accused are a husband and wife who run a physical rehabilitation center and their accomplice, an 80-year-old woman who

“…helped recruit seniors to sign blank medical forms and turn over their Medicare beneficiary ID numbers in exchange for $100 payments…”

Early last year, after being astonished at the number of news stories about Medicare fraud that randomly popped into my inbox from various news alerts, I began keeping a running list of URLs to those stories. My so-called “research” was casual, completely unscientific. I just saved them when I happened to notice and undoubtedly missed many.

Keep that in mind as you read this dollar amount of Medicare fraud from those 2008 stories I saved: $3.83 billion.

Apparently, that number is a small drop in the bucket, as I discovered on Monday looking into Medicare fraud around the web more seriously than I had last year.

South Florida is said to be the nation’s epicenter of this fraud which has been described as “rampant.” During the past few years, R. Alexander Acosta, who is the area’s U.S. Attorney, made prosecuting Medicare fraud a priority.

”In one operation, agents set out to survey and inspect every medical equipment company listed as having taken Medicare money in Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach counties - 1,581 places in all.

"’I wanted really, really tough criteria," [Acosta] said sarcastically. "One: Are they there? Two: Are they open? Three: Do they have a telephone?

"’Guess how many failed: 491,’ he said. ‘One out of three. They didn't exist.’"
- Palm Beach Post, 31 January 2009

Acosta says his office detected $1.5 billion in Medicare fraud in the past three years, but estimates the real number is closer to $8 or $10 billion. That’s just in one small corner of one state.

Estimates of annual dollar loss to Medicare fraud are hard to come by. One report, dated 1997, from the National Center for Policy Analysis then estimated $33 billion per year. Whatever the number today, and it is undoubtedly much larger and the majority of fraud goes undiscovered.

The medical device business is one of the biggest targets for fraud, but Medicare fraud takes many forms: false claims, phony prescriptions, inflated billing, billing for nonexistent services and much more. The saddest part to learn is that physicians themselves have been convicted.

However, tracking down and prosecuting miscreants pays off in a big way. In a July 2007 study [pdf], Jack Meyer, president of the Economic and Social Research Institute, reported that

”…for every dollar spent to investigate and prosecute health care fraud in civil cases, the federal government receives $15 dollars back in return.”

The oldest of the baby boomers will become eligible for Medicare in 2011, just two years from now, and Medicare is estimated to remain solvent only until 2018. Healthcare is a priority for President Obama and proposals for changes will be forthcoming, including Medicare. Whatever they are, it is obvious that fighting fraud will go a long way toward having the funds needed to reform healthcare. As Mr. Meyer noted in his report:

”With an aging population and sharply rising Medicare spending (even before the baby boomer demographic wave has hit the shore), we cannot afford a major drain on the Medicare program from fraud. Every dollar that is siphoned off from the program’s funding sources by fraudulent billing practices makes the painful choices we face in assuring Medicare’s solvency even harder.

“If fraud is not curtailed, it will be paid for by those enrolled in the program in the form of future benefit cuts and by working-age people in the form of higher taxes. Fraud will also be paid for by honest physicians, hospitals, and other healthcare providers whose rates will be further cut to help control the cost of the program. Each of these parties - seniors, taxpaying workers, and health care providers - has a financial stake in curtailing health care fraud.”

The job of enforcement is clearly up to federal authorities, but you and I can do our part too.

  1. Give out your Medicare ID number only to medical professionals who need it to bill for services delivered, and to Medicare itself

  2. Report a lost or stolen card immediately

  3. Check Medicare statements for double billing

  4. Check Medicare statements for services not provided and equipment not delivered

  5. Check Medicare statements for higher cost services and products than what was provided

There are more tips for detecting Medicare fraud here. Instructions for reporting Medicare fraud are here.

[At The Elder Storytelling Place today, Norm Jenson has a brief, little tale entitled, Nap Time.]


We should all be on the lookout for fraud of any type!

Of course, it would help if Medicare sent out statements more than quarterly....

My Brother in Law at age 92 tripped and sprained his knee.

First, he was taken by ambulance to the hospital,put in a semi private room. They Xrayed his knee and found nothing broken. Not satisfied with that diagnosis, they had to do an MRI. Same result. Slight strain.

They kept him in the hospital for 10 days and would release him only to a Rehab Center. He spent 2 weeks at the center lifting 1 pound weights and wondering how this would help his knee.

Cost to Medicare: $69,000

My Grandson, aged 14, tripped and sprained his knee. He was driven to the hospital by his mom and the doctor gave him an icepack and instructions to come back later if his swelling didn't go down.

Cost to Mom's Insurance Co. $150.00

Hmmm. I wonder why Medicare is always on the verge of insolvency....

Nancy points out an excellent reason for us to use our own judgment in asking for or accepting treatment. We need to speak up and go home instead of allowing ourselves to be incarcerated!

It would be interesting to know how Medicare fraud compares with the degree of fraud in medical systems in other countries. Is the amount of fraud in Canada and England, for instance, equal to ours? If not, is there something in the way our system is run that invites this sort of thing? I believe that our administrative costs are very high, and that part of the high cost is due to the complexity of regulations designed to prevent fraud. Is this complexity actually having the contrary effect of making fraud easier? Just a thought.

After the years of managing my Mom's paperwork, personally, I would never attempt to report fraud on any health insurance account. I'd be afraid I'd never get anything covered again. (Mom's Medicare account was red-flagged because of a car accident and, long years after the case was settled, we couldn't get them to remove the flag.)

Thanks, Ronni, for this terrific public service. As I read the HHS information, I wondered why the agency would not include it when a person registers for Medicare.

I'll do my small part by copying and posting in my building.

My policy covers free transportation to medical appointments. I only used it once because a taxi picked me up and charged $20 to take me less than a mile. The return trip for the exact same route was $40. I reported it, but never heard back. I doubt that anything was done.

I requested a breakdown from the hospital for the charges on my Cochlear Implant. It was over $100,000 for outpatient surgery. After three requests I gave up. I know the charge was outrageous.

I was amazed and slightly appalled
when I heard about my friend's mother who became seriously ill while visiting her daughter here in Atlanta from her home in New York City.

Her mother was 87 years old, after a hospital stay of about a week and a month in extended care she returned to her daughter's home. Her mother required physical therapy and respiration therapy.

This was the wasteful part that was paid for by Medicare:

One physical therapist came out to the home in the mornings to provide therapy for her "upper body."

In the afternoons another physical therapist came out to administer physical therapy to her "lower body." All the while this poor woman could barely move about at all.

They also ended up with TWO wheel chairs paid for by Medicare.Tried to return one to no avail. So they just gave up.

She died two months later in the nearby nursing home.

Medicare is an outstanding program but they need to control the costs and fraud.

I am glad that you wrote about this. You've assembled a good set of facts. Plus, consumers of all ages need to be more aware of the various ways they can be affected by identity theft and fraud. The only additions I would make to your post:

1. Report medicare fraud:

2. Report other fraud to the FTC:

2. Report fraud to local law enforcement


Fake Medical Device Maker Convicted:

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)