Blended Generations, Blended Technology

ELDER MUSIC: The Songs of Gerry Goffin and Carole King

Tibbles1SM100x130This Sunday Elder Music column was launched in December of 2008. By May of the following year, one commenter, Peter Tibbles, had added so much knowledge and value to my poor attempts at musical presentations that I asked him to take over the column. He's been here each week ever since delighting us with his astonishing grasp of just about everything musical, his humor and sense of fun. You can read Peter's bio here and find links to all his columns here.

Carole King & Gerry Goffin

The recent death of Gerry Goffin has brought to the fore all those great songs he wrote in the sixties with his then wife Carole King. He also wrote with others later and he won Oscars, Tonys and pretty much every other award around for music. Today, though, we're using those first songs.

Gerry and Carole met at Queens College and they started writing songs together in the evenings. After they graduated, they got married and continued their song-writing together at the famous Brill Building, a mecca for such activity at the time.

Mostly, Gerry wrote the words and Carole the music, at least until she became a solo artist in her own right when she performed both functions (as well as singing and playing the piano, of course).

I'll start with one of their earliest songs, a mini teenage opera performed by THE SHIRELLES.

The Shirelles

The song is Will You Love Me Tomorrow? and it has been covered by many over the years but none perform it as well as they do. The Shirelles' singing, and especially lead vocalist Shirley Owens (later Aston), captured the angst of teenager love (and to put no fine point on it, sex) better than anyone.

♫ The Shirelles - Will You Love Me Tomorrow

GENE MCDANIELS started out as a gospel singer and then switched to jazz. Not just singing, but he was a fine sax and trumpet player as well.

Gene McDaniels

In the early sixties, he had a string of hits that were the equal or better than anything else around at the time. He later produced records and became an acclaimed songwriter.

His song today is one of those aforementioned hits, Point Of No Return.

♫ Gene McDaniels - Point Of No Return

One of the songs that I was surprised to learn was written by our duo, especially as Gerry wrote the words, is one of ARETHA FRANKLIN's biggest hits: (You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman.

Aretha Franklin

The song came into being when Jerry Wexler, honcho for Atlantic Records where Aretha recorded, encountered Carole on the streets of New York and said he wanted a song about a natural woman for Aretha. This is the result.

The song has been covered by many artists including, rather surprisingly, Rod Stewart (who does a rather good job of it). Carole's own version on the "Tapestry" album is interesting too, and quite different from Aretha's with just piano and bass accompaniment.

♫ Aretha Franklin - (You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman

I was playing this next track and Norma, the Assistant Musicologist, said, "You'd better include that one." I was going to in any case but there's no way I could omit it now. It's from BLOOD SWEAT AND TEARS.

Blood, Sweat & Tears

The track is Hi-De-Ho, sometimes prefixed or suffixed by That Old Sweet Roll.

♫ Blood, Sweat & Tears - Hi-De-Ho

By the time they recorded the album "The Notorious Byrd Brothers,” THE BYRDS had been reduced to a duo, Roger McGuinn and Chris Hillman.

Roger McGuinn & Chris Hillman

Of the other original members, Gene Clark left because he didn't like touring, especially flying, David Crosby was kicked out because of "artistic differences" and Michael Clarke was kicked out just before he decided to leave.

In spite of all that, the remaining pair produced a fine album that contained two Goffin/King songs, Goin' Back and Wasn't Born to Follow, both worthy of inclusion.

I've decided on Wasn't Born to Follow.

♫ The Byrds - Wasn't Born To Follow

THE DRIFTERS recorded several songs by our pair. Not just them, but Ben E. King, the lead singer of their best songs, did so as well as a solo artist.

The Drifters

They were all so good it was pretty much a roll of the die as to which I should include. As it came up 6 (okay, I didn't do that), Up on the Roof is the one I'm using.

♫ The Drifters - Up On The Roof

DUSTY SPRINGFIELD recorded several Goffin/King songs, including the two mentioned above recorded by The Byrds as well as the Blood Sweat and Tears track. It was a matter of juggling all three and seeing who I'd like doing which.

Dusty Springfield

The answer is obvious by now as I've decided on the other two, so that leaves Dusty performing Goin' Back.

♫ Dusty Springfield - Goin' Back

BOBBY VEE's start in show biz wasn't under the most salubrious circumstances – he took over from Buddy Holly on the Winter Tour after Buddy and the others were killed in the plane crash.

Bobby Vee

He's generally not thought of too highly and I don't understand that. His songs still hold up today and I like them a lot (okay, I liked them at the time as well).

It's time for his reputation to be rehabilitated. I'll start that by playing Take Good Care of My Baby, one of a couple of Goffin/King compositions he recorded at the time.

♫ Bobby Vee - Take Good Care Of My Baby

Now one that even The Beatles covered, Chains. However, going with my (almost general) policy of playing the original, I give you THE COOKIES.

The Cookies

The Cookies were Little Eva's backing singers. Eva was initially Gerry and Carole's baby sitter and for whom they wrote The Locomotion. She also sang backing vocals of this song. However, this isn't Eva's turn, it's time for The Cookies.

♫ The Cookies - Chains

Although GENE PITNEY was a songwriter who wrote for himself and others, he wasn't averse to recording other people's material as well.

Gene Pitney

That's handy for us today as we can include him singing Every Breath I Take (no relation to the later Sting song with a similar name).

♫ Gene Pitney - Every Breath That I Take


Wonderful Goffin-King memories and interesting background on some favorite singers. My first boss (1966) was Carole King's dad, Sid Klein. There was a photo of Little Eva over his desk.

Glad you were able to find an opportunity to use the word salubrious :-)

I'm pretty sure I have never heard the Springfield version of Goin' Back so thanks for that find.

The sheer magnitude of the creative force in Goffin-King just BLOWS MY MIND! Thanks for this little trip through what was one of the most exciting times to have ears. Every week; something jaw-dropping and amazing on the radio dial! I feel so lucky to be born when I was when I hear these tunes. Thanks for the work you do in choosing these incredible songs.

These songs helped define the 60s and 70s for me and many others. I'm embarrassed to admit that until recently I didn't know that the words to "Narural woman" and "Will you still love me tomorrow" were not written by Carole herself. I was amazed to find that a man had written the words to these and other songs that so perfectly reflected a woman's feelings. Which is why I would love to hear what Rod Stewart did with "Natural Woman." Some of the Goffin-King songs I still hear frequently, but thanks for reminding us of the many other great ones.

Thanks for your nice retrospective on Gerry Goffin, and my favorite musical era, the early 60's! Just want to add to your comments about rehabilitating Bobby Vee's musical reputation. Despite his great hits from that era, he is mostly dismissed as a "manufactured teen idol" (at least by those who think the British invasion saved us from him and other Bobbys..). Bobby is basically hardly thought of at all. Which is so unfair. Not just a singer of other people's songs, Bobby has always been a skilled rhythm guitarist, and also continued to write, compose, record, and release music from his home recording studio. And he only recently retired from touring in 2011, due sadly to Alzheimer's disease, but he kept recording and released his final album, The Adobe Sessions, in February 2014. Some may know that Bob Dylan was in Bobby's original band in 1959, before either was famous. Last July, Bob performed in Bobby's home state(Bob's too)of Minnesota, and Bobby was in attendance. Bob unexpectedly spoke, paying an amazing tribute to Bobby, and then performed Bobby's song Suzie Baby for the crowd. Bobby's website has much information about his career, and links to information about his new album... which was mostly recorded with his musician family live in his Tucson garage. One of the videos of the Dylan tribute is here.

Will you still love me tomorrow...those were the days

Awesome choices, Peter. Simply awesome.

Vermont Public Radio's Joel Najman just did two shows on this songwriting duo. It was awesome.

Solid post, Peter, and I'll add my support for Bobby Vee. In fact, I featured him on the Geezer Music Club back in 2009.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)