The Terrible Consequences of Sleep Deprivation – Part 1

ELDER MUSIC: Romeo and Juliet

Tibbles1SM100x130This Sunday Elder Music column was launched in December of 2008. By May of the following year, one commenter, Peter Tibbles, had added so much knowledge and value to my poor attempts at musical presentations that I asked him to take over the column. He's been here each week ever since delighting us with his astonishing grasp of just about everything musical, his humor and sense of fun. You can read Peter's bio here and find links to all his columns here.

* * *

Old Will Shakespeare created the most famous lovers in history. Of course, things didn't end too well for them.

It's instructive that Juliet was 13 years old, or "she hath not seen the change of fourteen years" to be exact. Romeo's age is not stated so there seem to be conflicting ideas about this; everywhere between 13 also and mid twenties. That latter age sounds a bit creepy to modern audiences.

The thing about this is that, in spite of her age, Juliet is easily the most mature character in the play. Not just more so than Romeo and his friends, but all the adults as well who carry on their silly vendetta.

So, songs about them separately and together.

This column came about when Norma, the Assistant Musicologist, and I watched a vid of a DIRE STRAITS concert.

Dire Straits

We saw the Straits way back, both as the original quartet and their later incarnation as a somewhat bombastic big band. We preferred the original, stick-in-the-muds that we are (well, I am. I wouldn't categorize the A.M. that way).

Naturally, they played one of their most popular and entertaining songs, Romeo and Juliet. "Ah," we said, and a column was born.

The song came from their third album, "Making Movies," when they were a trio as David Knopfler had left by then. This was just before their big band era.

♫ Dire Straits - Romeo and Juliet

STEVE FORBERT has made an honest living singing and writing songs for several decades now.

Steve Forbert

I always thought he could be a contender, achieve more than he has, however, he seems to be doing okay. Early on he had a hit with his song, Romeo's Tune. The distinctive piano playing on that track was by Bobby Ogdin, who used to play in Elvis's band.

There's a warning to this one but not your usual one. No, I find that this song is a real earworm. You'll be singing it for a week; well I will be. Actually, the previous song is a bit earwormy as well.

♫ Steve Forbert - Romeo's Tune

The story is a favorite of opera composers. For this first selection in that vein, I had considerable choice - Maria Callas, Joan Sutherland, Diana Damrau and more. After playing a bunch of them, including those mentioned, this version was next.

The A.M. came in and said, "That one.” I was leaning towards it too. When I checked out NICOLE CABELL's photo, it was a done deal (so sue me, I'm a bloke).

Nicole Cabell

Here we have the aria Je veux vivre from "Roméo et Juliette" by CHARLES-FRANÇOIS GOUNOD. Nicole sings (as Jules) that she would like to live inside her dream where it is eternally spring, rather than think about marriage.

♫ Nicole Cabell - Gounod ~ Romeo et Juliette ~ Je veux vivre

CAB CALLOWAY gained a whole new generation of fans when he had a prominent role in the Blues Brothers film.

Cab Calloway

Cab gives his song the standard Cab treatment. It's called Hi-De-Ho Romeo.

♫ Cab Calloway - Hi-De-Ho Romeo

I wasn't going to include the next track but the A.M. came in and said, "Play that again, it sounds like Bob Wills" - that's a good enough reason for her. The singer is GARTH BROOKS.

Garth Brooks

I hadn't really considered Garth and western swing to be synonymous, but I suppose he can do anything these days. Garth's song is Rodeo and Juliet.(Ho ho).

♫ Garth Brooks - Rodeo And Juliet

For a complete change of pace, I give you TOM WAITS.

Tom Waits

Tom gives his song a nice gentle romantic treatment. Okay, that's a bunch of lies, it's standard Tom and that's good enough for me. Romeo Is Bleeding.

♫ Tom Waits - Romeo Is Bleeding

THE REFLECTIONS had only one big hit and it's this one, (Just Like) Romeo and Juliet.

The Reflections

They had a few others that rattled around at the bottom of the charts. They kept on trucking though and are still performing today with a couple of their original members still present.

♫ The Reflections - (Just Like) Romeo & Juliet

For some reason the critics don't seem to like ELINA GARANČA very much. It's their loss, I think. The public loves her. I'm with the public.

Elina Garanca

She is a mezzo-soprano and I prefer the deeper tones of her singing to standard sopranos - Cecilia Bartoli sings in the same range. Here from the opera "I Capuleti ed i Montecchi" by VINCENZO BELLINI, is the aria, Se Romeo t'uccise un figlio, sung by the lovely Elina, without the usual (rather intrusive) chorus in the background.

♫ Elina Garanca - Se Romeo t'uccise un figlio

I really know nothing about PAUL PERRYMAN.


The lack of a booklet in the CD didn't help, and Dr Google let me down. I'll just play his song, Teenage Romeo.

♫ Paul Perryman - Teenage Romeo

LOU REED is an unlikely romantic.

Lou Reed

However, with Lou anything is possible including Romeo and Juliet. Actually, his song is called Romeo Had Juliette, which sounds more like the Lou we know and love.

♫ Lou Reed - Romeo Had Juliette


Elina Garanca - oh my, how lovely!

Good roundup, Mr. Tibbles. A companion piece might be the entire score of West Side Story...

Funny, Chuck..I thought the same thing, though none of the opera composers included an Officer Krupke in their versions of Tony and Maria.

As always, Peter, you hit the spot musically for me. I spent the weekend at what we here in Portland Oregon call "The Rose Festival" and so missed my blogs. Elina Garancia took the prize for her rendition of "Se Romeo t'uccise un figlio,"...she has a most lovely voice.

Keep up the good work you in Down Under Land, many of us look forward to your weekly offerings.

Elle in Unusually Hot Oregon..can we say climate change is here?

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)